Madewell | clothing
  • favorites

In 1972, American brand Pony declared NYC its stomping

grounds—so, naturally, its signature chevron-logo sneaker was born to, well, stomp around in. (That equestrian-sounding name? Actually an acronym for "Product of New York.") This season marks the long-awaited relaunch of its women's kicks—and this is one of the very few places that you can get them. In a fresh black and white design, these high-tops look as cool with jeans and a tee as they do with dresses. When you sel

  • Unisex sizing: Please size down 2 sizes; a size 4 is a women's size 6.
  • Man-made upper.
  • Rubber sole.
  • Import.
  • Item E8236

Pony® Topstar Hi High-Top Sneakers

$65.00$29.99(54% off)
Colorwhite black
Sale
WHITE BLACK
Out Of Stock
Sorry! This item was so popular, it sold out.
insider badgeEnjoy free shipping, a $25 birthday gift, points on
every purchase and more—it pays to be an Insider.
ortoday

Ratings + Reviews

4.0

reviewStarsreviewStars22 Reviews
insider badge
Madewell Insiders earn 10 points for every review.
search
Natalie97
  • Overall fitTrue to Size
  • WidthTrue to Size
reviewStarsreviewStarsAug 11, 2016

More stylish this time around

My 1st time ever owning PONY shoes! I really like them even though they aren't leather, they're a classic from my era! However the recommended sizing can be confusing, I am a true 9.5 women and 8 in men and unisex, but after speaking with a consultant, she recommend I get a size 7.5 which was too snugged. Re-ordered in my normal unisex size 8, perfect! So whatever your normal unisex size is, I would have to say true to size for these shoes, they aren't bigger than Vans, which was used for the sizing calculations. About to order the low tops!

Was this helpful?

ifonly37
  • Overall fitSlightly Small
reviewStarsreviewStarsJun 25, 2016

Super cute sneakers

I will say I wish these were real leather because I think these might scuff more easily, but otherwise I love them. They're comfortable and sleek and I love that the high top doesn't come up too high and make my legs look short. I normally wear a size 6, and ordered the 4.5/6.5 because that was all they had left. They fit great.

Was this helpful?

Lilu
  • Overall fitRuns Large
reviewStarsreviewStarsApr 15, 2016

Great style

I only will comment on the size cuz the rest is as it is, perfect. The run big, I am 8EU then I ordered 6.5 which is equivalent but no, they were big :( I had to order again.

Was this helpful?

ck17
  • Overall fitTrue to Size
reviewStarsreviewStarsApr 01, 2016

Classic, sleek sneaker for city walking

Bought these when I was heading to Stockholm and Paris - perfect, stylish city sneaker that's comfortable for walking a lot. Note, they are men's sizing! It says it in the description but I wasn't paying attention and had to exchange them. You need to go two sizes down for women's. Looks and feels amazing though!

Was this helpful?

BGrace
  • Overall fitTrue to Size
reviewStarsreviewStarsMar 11, 2016

Old school style and comfort

Super comfy, look fresh and modern with dresses and jeans. Thinking of buying another pair as backup for when I wear this pair out - I love them that much.

Was this helpful?

TXNYC
  • Overall fitRuns Large
reviewStarsreviewStarsMar 10, 2016

Sweet Kicks

I love these shoes and get complements on them every time I wear them! They look great with dresses or jeans and the are very comfortable. I sized down 1.5 sizes as suggested, and they still are a little wide - but in a normal comfortable sneaker way and I wouldn't swap for a smaller size.

Was this helpful?

LauraM
reviewStarsreviewStarsMar 10, 2016

Wonderful purchase

Have been wearing these nonstop since I got them. They have a great, classic look and the quality is excellent. I normally wear an 8.5 so I ordered the 7 (as noted in the description to order a size and a half down) and they fit perfectly. Would highly recommend.

Was this helpful?

Danielle
  • Overall fitTrue to Size
reviewStarsreviewStarsFeb 27, 2016

Excellent quality & style

Although a little bulky, these shoes are perfect and comfortable! They fit as expected and came with white and black shoe laces. Absolutely love these shoes!

Was this helpful?

gab313
reviewStarsreviewStarsFeb 17, 2016

classic sneaker

classic sneaker that you can dress up or dress down. I love my pair!

Was this helpful?

PleasedontcallmeLiz
  • Overall fitTrue to Size
  • WidthTrue to Size
reviewStarsreviewStarsAug 27, 2016

I like them but . . . .

I like these sneakers but since they are man-made materials they don't breathe. I think this will be fine in the fall but in the dead of summer it is a little rough. Sometimes they get a little squeaky too which I think is also because they are not real leather. Overall though they are comfortable and I like the look.

Was this helpful?